When it comes to hiring pricing talent, one of the most common and consequential decisions companies face is whether to prioritize industry experience or recruit from outside their vertical. Should a medtech firm only consider candidates with life sciences backgrounds? Can a former SaaS pricing director succeed in industrial manufacturing? Will someone from CPG thrive in a B2B subscription model?

The short answer: It depends.

As an executive recruiter specializing in pricing and commercial leadership roles, I’ve seen both approaches succeed—and fail. In this article, we’ll break down the advantages of hiring inside vs. outside the industry, what to consider when evaluating candidates, and why the best pricing leaders often bring a hybrid skill set that transcends verticals. This insight is especially relevant as pricing continues to evolve from a reactive function into a core strategic lever across sectors.

The Case for Hiring from Inside the Industry

1. Faster Onboarding & Contextual Knowledge
Pricing is deeply contextual. Industry veterans understand your buyer personas, sales channels, regulatory constraints, and value drivers from day one. That means less time ramping up and more time solving problems.

2. Instant Credibility with Sales & Product Teams
If your new pricing hire has "walked the halls" of a competitor or served the same customers, they gain instant trust with frontline sales and product stakeholders. This can be crucial when rolling out new pricing models or discount controls.

3. Familiarity with Commercial Models
Every industry has its own pricing nuances—tiered distribution in medtech, usage-based pricing in SaaS, promotions in retail, or part-number complexity in industrials. Hiring someone who’s lived these challenges reduces the learning curve and avoids costly trial-and-error.

4. Regulatory and Legal Awareness
In regulated industries (e.g., pharma, insurance, defense), the pricing function is intertwined with compliance. Having someone who knows the legal guardrails, rebate structures, and reporting requirements can reduce risk and avoid costly mistakes.

The Case for Hiring from Outside the Industry

1. Fresh Perspectives & Innovation
If your industry is stuck in outdated pricing practices (e.g., cost-plus or manual quoting), hiring from outside can infuse modern thinking. Candidates from tech or consulting often bring best practices in value-based pricing, software automation, and pricing governance that drive transformation.

2. Transferable Complexity
Pricing is a discipline rooted in logic and problem-solving. If a candidate has successfully priced 10,000 SKUs across global markets or launched dynamic pricing in a high-velocity B2C environment, they likely have transferable skills, even if they don’t know your product yet.

3. Broader Commercial Acumen
Pricing leaders from outside your industry often bring broader exposure to commercial strategy, customer segmentation, packaging, and go-to-market design. These perspectives are often critical during periods of business model evolution or digital transformation.

4. Talent Scarcity
In many industries, seasoned pricing leaders are in short supply. Restricting your search to a narrow vertical can limit your options. Broadening your scope increases your chances of finding high-impact candidates with the hunger and capability to scale.

What to Prioritize: Skills Over Titles

Rather than fixating on industry familiarity, focus on these five high-leverage traits when evaluating pricing talent:

1. Analytical Rigor
Have they built pricing models, run elasticity studies, or led segmentation work? Can they speak to KPIs like price realization, win-rate impact, and contribution margin?

2. Change Management Experience
Have they introduced new pricing models, implemented pricing tools, or restructured incentive systems? Can they navigate resistance and drive alignment across functions?

3. Cross-Functional Influence
Can they collaborate with Sales, challenge assumptions in Finance, and align with Product Marketing? Pricing leaders must be strong communicators and politically astute.

4. Systems & Tool Familiarity
Experience with CPQ platforms, ERP integrations, or pricing optimization tools (like PROS, Zilliant, Pricefx) is increasingly important, especially in digital or global businesses.

5. Strategic & Commercial Thinking
Do they see pricing as a tactical lever or a strategic function? Have they influenced C-suite decisions, shaped pricing roadmaps, or contributed to revenue strategy?

When to Hire Inside the Industry

• You operate in a highly regulated or complex compliance environment (e.g., pharma, aerospace).
• Your pricing role requires deep customer and channel knowledge.
• You need someone who can gain immediate trust from internal stakeholders.
• The role is executional and speed-to-impact matters more than transformation.

When to Hire Outside the Industry

• You’re undergoing a pricing transformation or looking to modernize your pricing approach.
• You want to introduce new tools, automation, or analytics capabilities.
• Your industry lacks a deep bench of pricing talent.
• You're building a new pricing function from scratch or launching a new business model.

Final Thoughts

Great pricing leaders aren’t defined by the logo on their last business card—they’re defined by how they think, lead, and drive impact. The best talent combines deep commercial acumen, technical fluency, strategic orientation, and the soft skills required to drive change.

While industry experience can accelerate the onboarding process, don’t let it overshadow transferable skills and long-term value creation potential. Some of the most successful pricing transformations we’ve seen came from leaders who brought ideas from different sectors and challenged the status quo.

At Jennings Executive Search, we help companies make smart, strategic hiring decisions that unlock pricing as a growth lever. We understand what makes pricing talent successful and how to identify leaders who can drive measurable results, whether they come from your industry or beyond it.

If you're hiring for a pricing role or exploring your next move as a pricing leader, let’s talk.

About Jennings Executive Search
Jennings Executive Search is a retained search firm exclusively focused on placing top-tier talent in pricing, monetization, and commercial strategy roles. With deep specialization in pricing across industries—from SaaS and industrials to healthcare, logistics, and manufacturing—we know what separates good from great. Our clients range from PE-backed growth-stage firms to Fortune 500 leaders undergoing pricing transformation. Whether you're hiring your first pricing manager or a global VP of Pricing Strategy, we bring unmatched network depth, speed, and insight into the talent that drives revenue and margin impact. Learn more at jenningsexec.com.

‍