8 Best Practices for Reviewing Resumes: An Employer’s Guide (+ Resume Review Checklist)
Did you know that only 35% of candidates applying to an open position will be qualified? There are an average of 118 applicants per open position, giving hiring managers a lot to sift through with few truly qualified candidates.
With that in mind, hiring managers need to be able to review resumes effectively. Given the complexity of doing so, this is no easy task.
Don’t fear! Here’s everything you need to know about reviewing resumes to ensure you find the best candidates. We’ve also included a resume review checklist at the end.
Step 1: Know Who’s Truly Qualified
The first part of reviewing resumes is figuring out who’s qualified and who’s not. Inevitably, part of your review process will include looking at resumes that belong to underqualified candidates. As a hiring manager, you’ll need to be able to disseminate this quickly.
To help prevent an abundance of underqualified candidates from applying, write thorough job descriptions. Giving candidates a clear understanding of who you’re looking for helps them self-select.
Step 2: Know What to Look For
Considering 52% of talent acquisition leaders feel screening for the correct candidates from a large pool is the most difficult part of their job, you want to do everything you can to simplify the process. Thus, create a resume evaluation matrix or resume review checklist.
Here are some aspects to watch out for:
- Work history (impact, revenue gained, new processes, etc.)
- Specific skills demonstrated
- Work gaps (candidates should be able to explain these)
- Moments of leadership, initiative, or collaboration
- Promotions or career shifts
- Errors in the resume
Step 3: Understand the Hiring Market
Reviewing resumes is a process that should be contextualized. The state of the job market determines how strict you can be on requirements and the breadth of candidates you’ll consider.
The job market is experiencing a weird set of circumstances in the US. On the one hand, the labor shortage still exists; on the other, we’re seeing layoffs and hiring freezes.
Despite the potential economic downturn, this is still a hyper-competitive market. Candidates expect excellent salaries, benefits, flexible work, and to be treated with respect.
Companies can’t afford to be overly picky when reviewing resumes. Consider offering on-the-job training to fill any skill gaps if you find a candidate who isn’t perfectly qualified but has the potential.
Step 4: Look for Red Flags
There are some red flags to look out for when reviewing resumes:
- Employment gaps: if a candidate properly explains a gap, no problem. If not, this is a major oversight.
- No upward movement. A long career with no upward trajectory could indicate a candidate lacks motivation.
- Typos or other errors. Errors can indicate a lack of attention to detail or care. Candidates should proofread resumes relentlessly.
- Job-hopping. There’s nothing wrong with regularly switching jobs. But too many employers in a short period (a few years) could indicate a lack of commitment. You don’t want to take the time and expense to onboard someone only to have them leave in a few months.
Step 5: Look for Personalized Messaging
A candidate probably isn't a standout if resumes or cover letters are copied and pasted across multiple jobs. Look for tailored messaging that is relevant to the company and role.
Does the candidate emphasize skills and qualifications relevant to the role? Do they discuss their excitement for this company? Top talent will take the time to do this.
Step 6: Scan for Relevant Keywords
Whether you use an applicant tracking system or not, look for relevant keywords when reviewing resumes. These are words or phrases specific to the role. Candidates should make these easy to find.
Step 7: Beware Too Many Buzzwords
Buzzwords are essential to a great resume because they help demonstrate impact. However, excessive jargon and buzzwords can be designed to make a candidate sound qualified in place of actual qualification.
Some buzzwords and power words include:
- Communicated
- Achieved
- Created
- Increased
- Managed
- Experienced
- Improved
- Decreased
- Utilized
- Responsible for
If candidates use more than one of these per line in a resume, that’s too much. If the resume feels stuffed with these words, that’s a bad sign. Be on the lookout for this when reviewing resumes.
Step 8: Keep an Open Mind
Especially in today’s market, reviewing resumes with an open mind is to your benefit.
Some of your best hires may not be perfectly qualified but are passionate, driven, and willing to learn. Your resume review checklist should be strict but not inflexible.
Know what knowledge can be gained on the job by a smart employee. Tantamount to this is clearly understanding required qualifications and preferred ones. If a candidate’s background is nontraditional, consider pursuing them if they pique your interest.
Your Resume Review Checklist
Now that you know how to evaluate resumes effectively, here’s a resume review checklist you can use.
Contact Info & Appearance
- Free of grammar and spelling errors?
- Contact info at the top and updated?
- Appropriate formatting (font, size, margins)?
- One page?
Summary
- Included?
- Evidence of experience or interest?
- Does this match the skillsets required for the job?
Education
- Listed correctly with college, date, and major?
- Does this educational background enhance the candidate’s qualifications?
Professional Experience
- Are experiences listed in reverse chronological order?
- Are the correct sections included (title, employer, location, month/year)
- Is applicable information under each header listed with bullet points?
- Is the past tense used for prior experience?
- Is present tense used for the current job?
- Does this work experience demonstrate impact, leadership, initiative, collaborative skills, or anything else relevant to the job?
- Are there employment gaps, and are they explained somewhere?
Other Possible Sections
Are any of the following included, and do they enhance candidacy? These are not necessary but may be relevant for particular roles:
- Research
- Technology
- Certifications
- Languages
- Professional associations
Need Help Filling Positions & Reviewing Resumes?
Reviewing resumes is an involved process, but it’s essential to making the right hire. This is especially true when it comes to executive or senior leadership positions.
If you’re feeling overwhelmed or need help making the correct hire, Jennings Executive can help. We’re here to match your company with the best senior leadership candidate possible. Learn more today!
Related: 8 Tips for Conducting Perfect Remote Interviews in 2022 and Beyond
Recommended For You
All About Employee Development And Why It’s Critical For Your Company’s Success
Read More >>
Video Conference Etiquette: Use These 8 Tips to Avoid Getting Fired for Improper Conduct
It may be hard to believe, but improper video conference etiquette can get you fired. According to Korn Ferry, 24% of executives admit to their firm firing staffers for virtual meeting errors. Yikes!
Read More >>
All About Emotional Intelligence for Leaders: Theories, Core Skills, and How to Improve
Emotional intelligence (EI) is a buzzword that’s gained traction over the last few years, but the theories surrounding it are at least two decades old.
Read More >>
The Importance of Feedback: 7 Undeniable Reasons Why Your Workplace Needs to Incorporate it
The importance of feedback in the workplace can’t be understated. Failing to foster a culture that encourages honest feedback can damage your company’s success.
Read More >>
Build a Winning CEO Succession Plan with These 6 Tips
Creating the perfect CEO succession plan is tricky, yet it’s one of the most essential steps a board can take. No decision has a more significant impact on your company’s future than selecting a new CEO.
Read More >>
America’s Labor Shortage: What’s Going On, and 4 Things Your Company Can Do About It
Since the start of the pandemic, America has been experiencing a labor shortage like never before. With more people quitting their jobs and companies desperately searching for candidates to fill open positions, organizations need to work harder to stand out.
Read More >>
7 Essential Tips for Hiring a CFO The Right Way
Hiring a CFO is a huge decision that will impact the lifeblood of your company: its financials. You want to get this decision right and do so efficiently.
Read More >>
What is an Executive Search Firm? Here’s Everything You Need to Know
Filling executive and senior positions can be daunting. Your company may lack the time, resources, or expertise to find the best candidates. As such, you may be considering an executive search firm.
Read More >>8 Best Practices for Reviewing Resumes: An Employer’s Guide (+ Resume Review Checklist)
Read More >>
Hiring a CTO The Right Way, According to an Executive Search Firm
Hiring a CTO for your business is a huge undertaking. There’s no exact science for when and how to hire a CTO since every business is different; however, there is knowledge you’ll need and best practices you can follow to help ensure success.
Read More >>
9 Expert Tips For Successfully Hiring Employees, According to an Executive Recruiter
Read More >>
Building a Future-Ready Finance Team: Skills, Adaptability, and the Role of Executive Search
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, finance teams play an instrumental role in guiding companies towards sustainable growth. The classic image of the finance professional crunching numbers in isolation has evolved. The modern finance professional is an analytical thinker, a strategic planner, and above all, adaptable to technological advancements. Building such a team is no small feat, and it requires a refined approach to talent acquisition and management.
Read More >>
How The Great American Credit Card Debt Crisis Influences Executive Talent Searches
Read More >>
Navigating the Future of Talent Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide for Recruiters
Welcome to our comprehensive guide on talent assessment in recruiting! In today’s competitive job market, finding and retaining top talent is crucial for the success of any organization. That’s why it’s essential for HR professionals, recruiters, and business leaders to have a deep understanding of talent assessment methods and their impact on productivity and attrition. In this guide, we will explore different talent assessment techniques, discuss the importance of talent assessment in recruiting, and provide insights on choosing the right talent assessment tools for your company. Additionally, we will delve into the implementation of a successful talent assessment and succession program. So, whether you’re a seasoned recruiter or just starting your career in HR, this guide will equip you with the knowledge and strategies to navigate the future of talent assessment effectively. Let’s get started on this exciting journey!
Read More >>
The Future of Work: Predictions for the 2024 Job Market
The future of work is a topic that continues to captivate our attention, as technological advancements and societal changes shape the landscape of employment. As we look ahead to the year 2024, it becomes increasingly important to consider the potential developments that may influence the job market. In this article, we will explore three key areas that are likely to have a significant impact on the future of work: emerging job roles, shifting skill demands, and the increasing prevalence of remote work.
Read More >>
Revolutionizing Recruitment: AI and Machine Learning
In the fast-paced world of recruitment, staying ahead of the competition is crucial. With the rapid advancements in technology, companies are now turning to artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning to revolutionize their recruitment processes. This innovative approach is transforming the way organizations find and attract top talent, making the entire hiring journey more efficient and effective. In this article, we will explore the role of AI in talent acquisition, the enhancement of candidate experience through technology, and the ethical considerations and bias mitigation that come with this new wave of recruitment.
Read More >>
Navigating Talent Shortages in M&A: Strategies for Success
In the fast-paced world of mergers and acquisitions (M&A), one of the biggest challenges companies face is navigating talent shortages. Finding and retaining top talent in this highly competitive landscape can make or break the success of an M&A deal. In this article, we will explore the root causes of talent shortages in M&A, as well as key strategies to overcome them. We will also delve into the importance of talent retention and discuss the future of talent management in the M&A industry.
Read More >>
The Evolution of Recruitment: Embracing Digital Transformation in Executive Search
In recent years, the field of recruitment has undergone a dramatic transformation. Gone are the days of relying solely on traditional methods to find the perfect candidate for executive roles. With the rise of digital transformation, recruitment practices have evolved to embrace innovative technologies and data-driven approaches. This article will explore the shift in recruitment practices, the role of technology in modern recruitment, the benefits and challenges of digital transformation, and the future of executive search in a digitized landscape.
Read More >>
The Impact of Remote Work on Executive Recruitment: Trends and Insights
The world of work has experienced a seismic shift in recent years, and one of the most significant changes has been the rise of remote work. As technology continues to advance and connect us in new ways, remote work has become more common and accepted. In this article, we will explore the impact of remote work on executive recruitment, examining the trends and insights that have emerged in this new era of work.
Read More >>
Diversity and Inclusion: Shaping the Future of Executive Search
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, diversity and inclusion have become more than just buzzwords. They have emerged as critical factors in shaping the future of executive search. As organizations strive to stay competitive and relevant, they are increasingly recognizing the importance of embracing diversity and fostering an inclusive environment. In this article, we will explore the significance of diversity and inclusion in executive search, examine the current state of affairs, discuss strategies for enhancing diversity and inclusion, highlight the impact on executive search, and look towards the future of a more diverse and inclusive approach.
Read More >>
The Rise of AI in Recruitment: Opportunities and Challenges
Technology has revolutionized various industries, and the world of recruitment is no exception. As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to advance, it is transforming the way companies find and hire talent. However, with every opportunity comes a set of challenges. In this article, we will explore the rise of AI in recruitment and delve into the numerous opportunities it presents, as well as the challenges that must be addressed.
Read More >>
Sustainability in Recruitment: Aligning Talent with Corporate Social Responsibility Goals
In today's competitive business landscape, sustainability has become a key focus for organizations across various industries. From reducing carbon emissions to promoting ethical practices, companies are increasingly adopting Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiatives to demonstrate their commitment to the planet and society. However, sustainability goes beyond just environmental efforts; it also encompasses talent acquisition and management. In this article, we will explore the concept of sustainability in recruitment and discuss how organizations can align their talent strategies with their CSR goals.
Read More >>
Salary Transparency in Recruitment: Trends, Benefits, and Challenges
In today’s competitive job market, attracting and retaining top talent is a priority for organizations. As a result, many companies are embracing the concept of salary transparency in recruitment. Understanding salary transparency, current trends, benefits, and challenges associated with this practice is crucial for both employers and job seekers. In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of salary transparency, analyze its benefits, and explore the challenges it presents.
Read More >>
Strategic Talent Acquisition: Aligning Recruitment with Business Goals
In today’s competitive business landscape, organizations are realizing the critical importance of strategic talent acquisition. Hiring the right people who can drive business success is no longer just a matter of finding candidates with the right skills and experience. It’s about aligning recruitment strategies with overall business goals to ensure long-term growth and sustainability. By adopting a strategic approach to talent acquisition, companies can attract, hire, and retain top talent that will propel their organizations to new heights.
Read More >>.png)
Balancing Technical Expertise and Leadership Skills
Striking the perfect balance between technical prowess and effective leadership skills is essential for success in today's dynamic work environment.
Read More >>
Beyond the Resume: Innovative Methods for Assessing Executive Potential
Discover groundbreaking methods for evaluating executive potential that go beyond the traditional resume.
Read More >>
Artificial Intelligence in Executive Recruitment
Discover how artificial intelligence is revolutionizing the executive recruitment process.
Read More >>
Candidate Experience: Recruitment Explained
Discover the key elements of candidate experience in the recruitment process.
Read More >>
Contingent Workforce: Recruitment Explained
Uncover the ins and outs of recruiting contingent workforce with our comprehensive guide.
Read More >>
Applicant Tracking System (ATS): Recruitment Explained
Uncover the ins and outs of Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) and revolutionize your recruitment process! Discover how this powerful tool streamlines hiring, enhances candidate experience, and boosts your company's talent acquisition efforts.
Read More >>
Recruiting for Revenue: Aligning Talent Strategies with Pricing Innovations
In today’s evolving business landscape, companies are constantly seeking innovative ways to drive revenue and stay ahead of the competition. One often overlooked aspect of revenue generation is the role of talent and how it intersects with pricing strategies. Successful companies understand that recruiting the right talent is crucial to achieving sustained growth and profitability. In this article, we will explore the importance of aligning talent strategies with pricing innovations, the role of recruitment in revenue enhancement, and discuss the future trends in revenue-driven recruitment.
Read More >>
Jennings Executive Search Welcomes Dan Wilkinson as Vice President of Strategic Initiatives & Client Success
Jennings Executive Search, a leading executive recruiting firm specializing in commercial strategy and pricing strategy recruitment, is pleased to announce the appointment of Dan Wilkinson as the Vice President of Strategic Initiatives & Client Success.
Read More >>
